How to Deal With an Underperforming Employee

Dealing with an underperforming employee is a delicate but necessary task for managers to ensure the productivity and success of their team. Handling the situation effectively requires a combination of empathy, clear communication, and a structured approach aimed at improvement rather than punishment.

Finding the Cause

First and foremost, it’s essential to identify the root causes of the employee’s underperformance. This may involve reviewing their work, analyzing feedback from colleagues and clients, and discussing concerns with the employee directly. Understanding whether the issue stems from lack of skills, motivation, resources, or external factors will determine the best course of action.

Honest Communication

Once the underlying reasons for underperformance are identified, managers should initiate an open and honest conversation with the employee. This discussion should take place in private and focus on specific behaviors or outcomes rather than personal criticism. Providing specific examples of where the employee’s performance fell short can help clarify expectations help foster an honest dialogue.

The Employee’s Viewpoint

During the conversation, it’s important to actively listen to the employee’s perspective and concerns. They may be facing challenges or obstacles that are affecting their performance, such as unclear expectations, insufficient training, or personal issues. By demonstrating empathy and understanding, managers can build trust and rapport with the employee, fostering a more collaborative approach to addressing the problem.

Improvement Plan

Following the initial discussion, managers should work with the employee to develop a personalized improvement plan. This plan should outline clear and achievable goals, along with steps to address areas of weakness and capitalize on strengths. Setting performance targets and milestones together can help keep the employee motivated and accountable for their progress.


During the improvement process, managers should provide ongoing feedback and support to the employee. This may involve regular check-ins to review progress, offer guidance, and make any necessary adjustments to the improvement plan. Recognizing and acknowledging incremental improvements can help boost morale and reinforce positive behaviors.

Lack of Improvement

In cases where the employee’s underperformance persists despite efforts to address it, managers may need to consider alternative interventions, such as additional training, reassignment of duties, or disciplinary action. However, it’s important to approach these measures with fairness, consistency, and a focus on finding solutions rather than assigning blame.

The overall goal of dealing with an underperforming employee should be to aid in their growth and development while maintaining the integrity and productivity of the team.

If you are looking for workers, check with Opti Staffing. We are one of the best staffing agencies in the region. We are one of the top staffing companies in Seattle and Anchorage. We also have a staffing agency in Tacoma, a temp agency in Vancouver, Washington, a staffing agency in Portland, and a staffing agency in Salem, Oregon. Give us a call today.